Unlike the delightful How Bad are Bananas, The Story of Stuff is a Manichean, hectoring lecture on the evils of the consumerist culture. And while I wholeheartedly agree that buying for the sake of buying, buying junk, and trashing perfectly functional objects are very objectionable behaviors, it did not take me more than a few dozen pages reading this book to find myself actively looking for loopholes and counter-examples to escape its simplistic arguments, which can be summed up thus: multinationals are by nature evil and they are the ones frcing us to behave as headless chickens. O, and all of us should patronize our frindly neighborhood farmer’s market and corner stores instead, since by definition they are not contributing to evil consumption. Says who? Perhaps the evil multinationals know a thing or two about supply chain economies of scale and perhaps they do manage to bring some goods to customers in a more ecologically-frinedly manner than the much vaunted corner store. But we don’t get any clear-headed discussions about that, although, oddly, we get an ode to a specific carpet company that, granted, seems to be doing some good recycling, but is still pushing synthetic carpeting over other materials that might be more earth-friendly.
I’d like a little more reasoning behind sweeping statements, please!