July 10, 2009...6:42 am

The Dawkins Delusion by Alister McGrath

Jump to Comments

The Dawkins Delusion is a rebuttal to Richard Dawkins’s  The God Delusion, which I found to be an intolerant and grating vituperation against religious people of all ilk that failed to distinguish between the lunatic fundamentalist fringe and the vast majority of religious folks who, it seems to me, are much more tolerant than Dawkins about others who may have different ideas than them.

This book is a learned rebuke to Dawkins’s book and idea which, in a wonderfully calm and measured manner, refutes the arguments made by Dawkins. No, it’s not child abuse to teach children about religion. No, believing in god is not  equivalent to believing in Santa Claus. No, science has not disproved the existence of god.

If you were disturbed by the crusade-like intensity of Dawkins’s attacks this is a welcome book. It would be good to hear directly from other atheists (some of whom are quoted in this book, thankfully) that not all of them advocate the raging extremism of Dawkins. Just like religious fundamentalists do not represent the bulk of religious people, Dawkins does not represent the bulk of atheists who are rather mild and even kindly-inclined people.

Leave a Reply